It sounds like the Cleveland Browns are facing some serious challenges in the 2024 season. Despite their strong defensive reputation in previous years, it seems like they haven’t been able to maintain that same level of dominance. Couple that with ongoing struggles in the passing game and quarterback position, and it’s clear that the team is at a crossroads.
Given that quarterback has been an issue for the Browns for a while now, it wouldn’t be surprising if they are planning for a long-term solution at the position. Perhaps they are looking to make a change either through the draft or via trade, with an eye toward finding a young, franchise-caliber quarterback who can lead the team into the future.
Cleveland Browns Make Controversial QB Decision
It seems like the Cleveland Browns are committed to moving forward with Deshaun Watson and Kevin Stefanski for the 2025 season, despite the struggles both have faced. Watson’s performance since joining the Browns has indeed been disappointing, especially considering the high expectations surrounding him after his trade from the Houston Texans in 2022. Injuries have been a factor this season, but his inconsistency and the overall lack of offensive production have raised doubts about his future in Cleveland.
Retaining both Watson and Stefanski suggests the Browns are either banking on a bounce-back season from Watson or that they feel continuity with Stefanski is important for the team’s development. With Watson’s massive contract, the Browns may feel they have little choice but to stick with him for at least another year to try and get some return on their investment.
This decision could also be influenced by the relatively weak pool of available quarterbacks this offseason. The Browns may hope that, with a healthy offseason, Watson can return to form and help lead the offense under Stefanski’s system.
https://twitter.com/nflrums/status/1861633747273081092?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw%7Ctwcamp%5Etweetembed%7Ctwterm%5E1861633747273081092%7Ctwgr%5E3e5eeec89453c07aa49c2b705e33bdf0c345a8a8%7Ctwcon%5Es1_&ref_url=https%3A%2F%2Fgridironheroics.com%2Fcleveland-browns-deshaun-watson-controversy%2F
Deshaun Watson Controversy
Deshaun Watson’s situation has undoubtedly made him one of the most controversial figures in NFL history. His legal battles stemming from allegations of sexual misconduct by multiple women in 2020 cast a long shadow over his career. Even after his suspension and the legal settlements, many fans, analysts, and players continue to criticize both his actions off the field and his performance on it.
On the field, Watson has struggled to live up to the immense expectations following his trade to the Cleveland Browns. After sitting out for the majority of the 2022 season due to his suspension, Watson has had a difficult time regaining the form he showed as one of the league’s most dynamic quarterbacks during his time with the Houston Texans. His lack of consistent play, combined with his off-field controversies, has only deepened the negative perception surrounding him.
For Browns fans and the organization, the situation is complex. Watson’s massive contract, which was structured in a way to minimize financial impact during his suspension, leaves the team with limited options for moving on from him easily. But the combined issues of his off-field controversies and on-field struggles create a difficult dynamic for the franchise moving forward. The Browns need a quarterback who can lead them, and while they may still hope Watson can regain his form, it’s understandable that many are skeptical about both his personal and professional future.
It will be interesting to see how the Browns handle this situation over the next year. If Watson continues to underperform or if the negative media attention continues to mount, the team could find itself facing even more scrutiny, especially if they stay committed to him as their long-term quarterback.
Deshaun Watson’s struggles since joining the Cleveland Browns have clearly left a sour taste with fans and the organization alike. The fact that Watson has only recorded 3,365 passing yards since his trade in 2022—despite the large expectations surrounding him—highlights the dissonance between what the Browns hoped for and what has actually transpired. His inability to return to his former Pro Bowl level of play has been a major disappointment, and now, with a season-ending injury in 2024, the situation is only growing more complicated.
The viral reaction from Browns fans cheering his injury is telling. It reflects the deep frustration many fans feel over Watson’s performance, both on the field and the controversy that continues to surround him off the field. It’s rare to see fans openly celebrate the misfortune of their own quarterback, but this reaction indicates how disillusioned some have become with Watson’s time in Cleveland.
Browns’ Dilemma: Financial Commitment and Fan Sentiment
As you’ve mentioned, the financial implications of moving on from Watson make it a difficult decision for the Browns. Given his fully guaranteed contract, which is one of the largest in NFL history, the Browns are in a tough position. They’d be on the hook for a significant portion of the salary even if they were to cut or trade him, which may be why they’re hesitant to move on from him too quickly. The reality is, cutting ties with Watson could cost the Browns a significant amount of cap space, which complicates their ability to improve other areas of the team, such as the offensive line or skill positions.
Should the Browns Draft a Rookie Quarterback?
The calls from Browns fans for a rookie quarterback signal that the team’s patience with Watson is wearing thin. However, as you pointed out, it doesn’t seem like the team is ready to make that move just yet. Drafting a rookie quarterback could signal a new direction for the franchise, but that would require careful planning, especially considering how much financial capital they’ve already invested in Watson. While the Browns do need a franchise quarterback for the future, they may not be willing to give up on Watson just yet, especially with the pressure of his massive contract looming.
Possible Paths Forward:
Draft a QB and Develop for the Future
While Watson remains on the roster, the Browns could look to the 2025 draft to secure a top quarterback prospect, either in the first round or through a trade-up. They could begin to develop this player behind Watson, eventually transitioning to the rookie if Watson continues to underperform. This would provide the Browns with a long-term solution without the immediate financial burden of moving on from Watson.
Focus on the Rest of the Roster
With Watson under contract, the Browns could look to strengthen other areas of the team, including the offensive line, skill positions, and defense. They may be hoping that Watson can find some semblance of form if he’s better protected and given more reliable weapons. This approach could help them win in the short term, but the lingering quarterback issue would remain unresolved for the future.
Consider a Trade or Restructure
If the Browns truly want to explore the quarterback market, they might have to consider trading Watson or restructuring his contract to make it easier to move on from him. This would likely be a difficult move given his contractual obligations and past performance, but it could free up the Browns to pursue a long-term solution, whether through a trade or the draft.
Ultimately, while the financial situation and Watson’s contract complicate the Browns’ ability to make bold changes at quarterback, the growing fan frustration and the team’s need for stability at the position may eventually force their hand.
How do you think the Browns should balance the financial commitment to Watson with the urgent need for a more productive and stable quarterback moving forward? Should they move on sooner, or should they ride out the contract and focus on other parts of the roster?
