Deshaun Watson’s comments about not wanting more designed quarterback runs added to the Cleveland Browns’ offense has stirred up criticism from fans and analysts alike, especially in light of his ongoing struggles as a passer.
ESPN’s First Take host Elle Duncan was particularly vocal in her critique, calling out Watson for his perceived lack of self-awareness, given his underwhelming performance on the field, despite his massive contract. Duncan emphasized that Watson, who signed a fully guaranteed $230 million deal, should be willing to adapt to any role the team requires to improve their chances of success—even humorously suggesting he should practice kicking if needed.
Watson’s desire to avoid more run-heavy responsibilities could stem from a desire to preserve his long-term health, but Duncan’s comments reflect the frustration that many feel over the gap between his paycheck and his current level of play. Watson’s refusal to embrace the “running quarterback” label may not sit well with those expecting more versatility from him, especially given his elite athleticism and ability to extend plays when at his best.
Deshaun Watson’s struggles with the Cleveland Browns are under heavy scrutiny, especially considering the team’s significant financial investment in him. After missing most of the 2022 season due to suspension related to allegations of sexual misconduct and then suffering a shoulder injury in 2023, Watson has yet to deliver the performance expected from a quarterback with a fully guaranteed $230 million contract.
Now, entering Week 4 of the current season, Watson’s statistical output ranks among the worst for starting quarterbacks. According to *Pro Football Reference*, he sits 30th in adjusted QBR (21.3) and dead last in passing success rate at 28%. These numbers have led to calls for head coach Kevin Stefanski to consider benching Watson in favor of backup Jameis Winston. ESPN’s Seth Walder and *Sports Illustrated’s* Conor Orr have both floated this idea, although there’s no official indication that Stefanski will make such a move soon.
Elle Duncan’s criticism of Watson on ESPN’s *First Take* adds to the growing frustration surrounding his performance. Duncan expressed disbelief over Watson’s refusal to embrace the “running quarterback” role, especially given his underwhelming play. She pointed out the disconnect between his performance and his high salary, calling his remarks about not wanting more designed run plays “arrogant” in light of his current struggles.
The pressure on Watson is palpable, particularly because Browns management—ownership and general manager Andrew Berry—may be inclined to stick with Watson due to the massive contract he signed. However, if Watson continues to falter in this Sunday’s game against the Las Vegas Raiders, especially considering the Raiders are 1-2 and were recently torched by backup Andy Dalton, Stefanski may be forced to reconsider his options. With the Browns potentially at risk of losing the locker room, a change at quarterback might be necessary to salvage the season.
Interestingly, the Raiders are listed as 1.5-point favorites, which underscores the level of uncertainty surrounding Watson and the Browns’ performance heading into the game.
